The Fair Isle Sweater Is Never Not in Style—Shop 32 of the Best


This season, however, designers from Proenza Schouler to Altuzarra are giving the fall fashion favorite a fresh spin. Take styling cues from the latter and pair Altuzarra’s roomy Fair Isle turtleneck with a modern midiskirt, knee-high riding boot, and statement leather belt for a look that transitions seamlessly from the countryside to the city streets.

Dôen’s chunky cardigan is another seasonal staple worth adding to your cart, best worn with a cozy corduroy pant, Balmoral-approved barn jacket, and sumptuous suede loafer. On the more minimalist side, Róhe’s two-toned Fair Isle crewneck and High Sport’s cropped turtleneck define understated elegance–two pared-back picks made for weekend gallery strolls to chic commuting. Bonus points if you layer yours underneath an elegant wrap coat or a slouchy leather bomber jacket.

For more ideas on how to wear your Fair Isle find now, turn to celebrities like Hailey Bieber and Katie Holmes, who’ve made it a cornerstone of their fall-in-the-city style. Regardless if you wear yours à la Bieber with a micro mini skirt and patent smoking loafer, or Holmes with a wide-leg cargo pant and sneaker, a Fair Isle sweater is a fall/winter 2025 staple meant to be yours this season (and the next!). Shop our favorite finds below, from crewnecks to cardis and vests that are charming as they are chic.

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Zara

jacquard jumper

The Nordic Scholar cardigan

Polo Ralph Lauren

Fair Isle cardigan

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Loewe

Fair Isle sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Nili Lotan

Chrissy sweater

Dôen

Clarke Fair Isle cardigan

Zara

brushed effect jacquard cardigan

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Madewell

Fair Isle sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

&Daughter

Fair Isle sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Hat, and Cap

Altuzarra

Marty Fair Isle sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Vest, Knitwear, Sweater, and Tank Top

Dôen

Vincent vest

Uniqlo

fluffy Fair Isle sweater

L.L.Bean

Bean's Classic ragg wool sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

H&M

jacquard-knit sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Arch4

Whistler Fair Isle sweater

Jenni Kayne

Thatcher crewneck sweater

Vince

Fair Isle polo sweater

Frame

The Cashmere Fairisle cardi

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, and Sweater

Alex Mill

Amina Fair Isle sweater

Veronica Beard

Christina Fair Isle cardigan

Dunst

crafted V-neck knit vest

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, and Sweatshirt

Staud

Zane sweater

Brunello Cucinelli

cropped turtleneck sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Sweatshirt, and Blouse

Guest in Residence

Fair Isle cardigan

Arch4

Snowmass Fair Isle sweater

Proenza Schouler White Label

Lizzy sweater

Khaite

Guy intarsia sweater

High Sport

Fair Isle turtleneck sweater

Image may contain: Clothing, Knitwear, Sweater, Sweatshirt, and Hoodie

Alix of Bohemia

Liza Fair Isle sweater

JW Anderson

intarsia wool sweater

Calle Del Mar

Winter Fair Isle half-zip sweater

Gucci

Norwegian wool jacquard sweater